Comprehensive Oil Filter Comparison: Expert Analysis of Top 5 Models (July 23, 2025)

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Here’s an overview of the Best Oil Filter that we’ll explore today:

1FRAM Extra Guard PH7317 10K Mile Change Automotive Replacement Interval Spin-On Engine Oil Filter for Select Vehicle Model Years
Top Pick

FRAM Extra Guard PH7317 10K Mile Change Automotive Replacement Interval Spin-On Engine Oil Filter for Select Vehicle Model Years

Check Latest Price
2Motorcraft FL-820-S Oil Filter
Best Quality

Motorcraft FL-820-S Oil Filter

Check Latest Price
3Motorcraft FL-500S Oil Filter

Motorcraft FL-500S Oil Filter

Check Latest Price
4Genuine Acura 15400-PLM-A02 Engine Oil Filter

Genuine Acura 15400-PLM-A02 Engine Oil Filter

Check Latest Price
5Motorcraft Oil Filter - FL2124S (Replaces FL2051S)

Motorcraft Oil Filter – FL2124S (Replaces FL2051S)

Check Latest Price

Oil filters are a critical component of engine maintenance, ensuring that contaminants such as dirt, metal particles, and sludge are kept out of your vehicle’s engine oil. Choosing the right oil filter can extend your engine’s life, improve performance, and save you money in the long run. In this comparative review, we analyze five popular oil filters across a range of price points and brands. Our methodology includes evaluating each product’s filtration efficiency, build quality, compatibility with different vehicles, and overall value for money. We’ll provide an unbiased assessment to help you make an informed decision, whether you’re looking for a budget-friendly option or a premium product.

Top Pick

FRAM Extra Guard PH7317 10K Mile Change Automotive Replacement Interval Spin-On Engine Oil Filter for Select Vehicle Model Years

1. FRAM Extra Guard PH7317 10K Mile Change Automotive Replacement Interval Spin-On Engine Oil Filter for Select Vehicle Model Years

  • Brand: Fram
  • Manufacturer: Fram

The FRAM Extra Guard PH7317 is a budget-friendly oil filter designed for everyday drivers who perform regular maintenance. With a price of just $4.12, it offers 10,000 miles of engine protection. Its proprietary blend of cellulose and glass media captures 95% of dirt particles, making it a reliable choice for conventional and synthetic motor oils. The silicone anti-drain back valve enhances engine protection during startup, while the SureGrip feature ensures hassle-free installation and removal. This product has been a bestseller for years, thanks to its affordability and consistent performance.

In terms of performance, the PH7317 excels in basic filtration, though it may not match the durability or advanced protection of premium filters. It’s ideal for drivers with older vehicles or those who change their oil frequently. However, the resin and fiber construction may not hold up as well under extreme conditions. While its dirt-trapping efficiency is impressive for the price, it’s best suited for light-duty use rather than high-performance vehicles.

Pros

  • Affordable price point
  • Captures 95% of dirt particles
  • Silicone anti-drain back valve for startup protection
  • Easy installation with SureGrip feature

Cons

  • Not ideal for high-performance or extreme conditions
  • Limited durability compared to premium options

Check Latest Price

Best Quality

Motorcraft FL-820-S Oil Filter

2. Motorcraft FL-820-S Oil Filter

  • Brand: Motorcraft
  • Manufacturer: Motorcraft

The Motorcraft FL-820-S is a mid-range oil filter priced at $8.44 and designed for vehicle-specific applications. Manufactured with high-quality materials, it effectively screens out abrasives like carbon, sand, and metal particles. The inclusion of a pressure-relief valve minimizes the risk of contaminated oil recirculating into the engine. With its universal fit, this filter is compatible with a wide range of vehicles, making it a versatile option for many drivers.

Performance-wise, the FL-820-S stands out for its robust construction and reliable filtration efficiency. It’s particularly well-suited for Ford vehicles, as it meets OEM standards. However, its heavier weight may make installation slightly more challenging. While it offers excellent value for its price, some users may find that it lacks the advanced features of higher-end filters.

Pros

  • High-quality construction
  • Effective filtration of contaminants
  • Pressure-relief valve prevents oil recirculation
  • Affordable mid-range option

Cons

  • Heavier than some competitors
  • Limited advanced features

Check Latest Price

Motorcraft FL-500S Oil Filter

3. Motorcraft FL-500S Oil Filter

  • Brand: Motorcraft
  • Manufacturer: Motorcraft

The Motorcraft FL-500S, priced at $8.44, is another strong contender in the mid-range category. Designed for Ford vehicles, it offers excellent protection against engine wear by efficiently filtering out harmful particles. The inclusion of pressure-relief valves ensures that contaminated oil doesn’t circulate back into the engine, a feature that enhances its reliability. Its polished exterior and steel construction add to its durability.

This filter is particularly well-suited for Ford models like the F-150 and Mustang, providing a snug fit and consistent performance. Its universal compatibility makes it a reliable choice for many vehicle types. However, its slightly smaller size may limit its dirt-holding capacity compared to larger filters. Overall, it delivers solid performance at a competitive price.

Pros

  • Durable steel construction
  • Pressure-relief valves for added protection
  • Optimized for Ford vehicles
  • Universal fit

Cons

  • Smaller size limits dirt-holding capacity
  • Best suited for Ford vehicles, limiting broader appeal

Check Latest Price

Genuine Acura 15400-PLM-A02 Engine Oil Filter

4. Genuine Acura 15400-PLM-A02 Engine Oil Filter

  • Brand: Honda
  • Manufacturer: Honda

The Genuine Acura 15400-PLM-A02 oil filter, priced at $10.84, is an OEM-quality product designed specifically for Honda and Acura vehicles. Its compact size and vehicle-specific fit ensure optimal performance for compatible models. While it lacks advanced features, its simplicity and reliability make it a popular choice among Honda owners.

This filter performs well in everyday driving conditions, offering consistent filtration and engine protection. However, its lightweight design may not inspire confidence in extreme conditions. It’s an excellent option for drivers who prioritize OEM compatibility and straightforward functionality over additional features.

Pros

  • OEM quality for Honda and Acura vehicles
  • Reliable filtration performance
  • Vehicle-specific fit ensures compatibility

Cons

  • Lacks advanced features
  • Lightweight design may not suit extreme conditions

Check Latest Price

Motorcraft Oil Filter - FL2124S (Replaces FL2051S)

5. Motorcraft Oil Filter – FL2124S (Replaces FL2051S)

  • Brand: Motorcraft
  • Manufacturer: Motorcraft

The Motorcraft FL2124S is the premium option in this lineup, priced at $22.99. Known for its high-quality construction and award-winning design, this filter is built to withstand demanding conditions. It’s particularly suited for trucks and heavy-duty vehicles, offering exceptional durability and performance. The polished exterior and robust metal construction add to its premium appeal.

With its advanced filtration capabilities and universal fit, the FL2124S is ideal for drivers seeking long-lasting performance. However, its higher price point may deter budget-conscious buyers. While it excels in heavy-duty applications, it may be overkill for everyday drivers with standard vehicles.

Pros

  • Exceptional durability and construction
  • Advanced filtration for heavy-duty applications
  • Universal fit for versatility
  • Premium design and materials

Cons

  • High price point
  • May not be necessary for standard vehicles

Check Latest Price

Frequently Asked Questions

We’ve compiled answers to the most common questions about oil filters to help you make an informed decision.

QWhat is the difference between budget and premium oil filters?
ABudget oil filters, like the FRAM Extra Guard, offer basic filtration and are ideal for frequent oil changes. Premium filters, such as the Motorcraft FL2124S, provide advanced filtration, durability, and are better suited for heavy-duty or long-term use.
QHow do I know which oil filter is compatible with my vehicle?
ACheck your vehicle’s owner manual or consult the manufacturer’s specifications. Many oil filter brands, such as Motorcraft, offer vehicle-specific options for optimal compatibility.
QAre OEM oil filters better than aftermarket ones?
AOEM filters, like the Genuine Acura 15400-PLM-A02, are designed to meet the exact specifications of your vehicle, ensuring compatibility and reliability. Aftermarket filters can offer similar performance but may vary in quality.
QHow often should I replace my oil filter?
AMost oil filters should be replaced every 5,000 to 10,000 miles, depending on the manufacturer’s recommendations and your driving conditions.
QCan I use a universal-fit oil filter on my vehicle?
AYes, universal-fit filters like the Motorcraft FL-820-S are designed to work with a range of vehicles. However, always verify compatibility with your specific model.

Conclusion

Choosing the right oil filter can truly enhance your game.

It offers convenience and makes walking the course easier. With various options available, it’s important to consider your needs.

Think about the cart’s weight, stability, and storage features. A good push cart can save you energy..

Leave a Comment