Here’s an overview of the Best Broadheads For Elk Hunting that we’ll explore today:
Elk hunting requires precision, power, and reliability, and the right broadhead can make all the difference in ensuring a clean, ethical kill. Broadheads are the critical component of your arrow that determines cutting efficiency, penetration, and flight accuracy. In this review, we tested five of the most popular broadheads available in 2025, ranging from budget-friendly options to premium models. Our methodology included rigorous testing for cutting diameter, penetration, flight stability, and overall durability across various setups, including compound bows, crossbows, and recurve bows. The products reviewed span a wide price range ($15.99 to $49.99) and include models from reputable brands such as TRUGLO, Dead Ringer, Bgary, Archery World, and Slick Trick.
1. Slick Trick XbowTrick 4pk
- Brand: Slick Trick
- Manufacturer: Slick Trick
The Slick Trick XbowTrick 4pk is a premium broadhead designed for hunters seeking unmatched precision and power. With a total cutting diameter of 2 1/4 inches, this model features .035 stainless steel blades and a Super Steel ferrule for maximum durability. Its patented Alcatraz Bladelock system ensures the blades stay securely in place upon impact, making it ideal for bone-splitting shots. Compatible with crossbows, compound bows, and recurve bows, the Slick Trick XbowTrick offers field-point flight performance, which is crucial for accuracy during long-range elk hunting. At $49.99, this broadhead is the most expensive in our lineup but delivers exceptional performance for serious hunters.
In testing, the Slick Trick XbowTrick demonstrated remarkable penetration and cutting efficiency, even in challenging scenarios involving dense bone and tissue. Its field-point flight characteristics ensured consistent accuracy across different bow types and setups. However, the high price point may deter casual hunters or those on a budget. Additionally, while the blades are durable, they require meticulous sharpening after repeated use to maintain their effectiveness. This broadhead is highly recommended for experienced hunters targeting large game like elk, where reliability and cutting power are paramount.
Pros
- Exceptional cutting diameter (2 1/4 inches)
- Durable Super Steel ferrule and blades
- Field-point flight for consistent accuracy
- Patented Alcatraz Bladelock system
Cons
- High price point ($49.99)
- Requires regular blade sharpening after use
2. Bowhunting 100 125 Grain
- Brand: Archery World
- Manufacturer: Archery World
The Bowhunting 100 125 Grain Broadhead from Archery World is a budget-friendly option priced at just $15.99 for a 12-pack. This model features a 3-blade design with a 1-inch cutting diameter and anodized aluminum ferrule for lightweight durability. The vented stainless steel blades offer cut-on-impact performance, making it a suitable choice for hunters who prioritize affordability and quantity. Compatible with crossbows, recurve bows, and compound bows, this broadhead is versatile and ideal for beginners or those practicing their shot consistency.
During testing, the Bowhunting 100 Grain Broadhead performed adequately in terms of penetration and flight stability. However, its smaller cutting diameter (1 inch) limits its effectiveness for larger game like elk, where a wider wound channel is preferred. The blades are sharp but lack the durability of premium models, requiring frequent replacement or sharpening. Despite its limitations, this broadhead offers great value for casual hunters or those on a tight budget, especially considering the quantity provided in a single pack.
Pros
- Affordable price ($15.99 for 12-pack)
- Lightweight anodized aluminum ferrule
- Cut-on-impact design with vented blades
- Versatile compatibility with multiple bow types
Cons
- Smaller cutting diameter (1 inch)
- Less durable blades compared to premium models
3. Dead Ringer unisex adult Dead Ringer The Butcher Broadhead 100 gr 3 pk
- Brand: Dead Ringer
- Manufacturer: Dead Ringer
Dead Ringer’s The Butcher Broadhead is a mid-range option priced at $26.83, designed for hunters seeking reliable penetration and bone-shattering performance. Featuring a cutting diameter of 1 1/16 inches and a total cutting surface of 1.725 inches, this broadhead is optimized for lower kinetic energy setups. The two large blades and two bleeder blades create devastating wound channels, making it ideal for elk hunting in dense environments.
In field tests, The Butcher excelled in creating clean, deep cuts, even with lower draw weight setups. Its design is particularly effective for hunters using recurve bows or compound bows with moderate kinetic energy. However, the slightly smaller cutting diameter compared to premium models limits its performance in creating larger wound channels. Additionally, the blades require careful maintenance to prevent dulling after extended use. Overall, Dead Ringer’s The Butcher is a solid choice for hunters balancing performance and affordability.
Pros
- Effective bone-shattering design
- Optimized for lower kinetic energy setups
- Durable construction with bleeder blades
- Affordable mid-range price
Cons
- Smaller cutting diameter (1 1/16 inches)
- Blades require frequent maintenance
4. Bgary Broadheads 100 Grain Archery Broadheads for Crossbow Recurve Bow
- Brand: Bgary
- Manufacturer: Bgary
The Bgary Broadheads are marketed as a versatile option for beginners and enthusiasts alike. Featuring a cutting diameter of 1–1 1/8 inches and three sharp stainless steel blades, this model is designed for durability and precision. Priced competitively, it provides a balanced option for hunters seeking reliable performance without breaking the bank. The hybrid tips ensure surgical precision, making it suitable for both practice and hunting scenarios.
While the Bgary Broadheads performed well in terms of flight stability and penetration, they struggled to match the cutting efficiency of premium models like the Slick Trick XbowTrick. The blades are sharp but can dull quickly after repeated use, requiring frequent sharpening or replacement. Additionally, the lack of a clear price point makes it challenging to assess its value relative to competitors. This broadhead is best suited for casual hunters and beginners who prioritize versatility and ease of use.
Pros
- Versatile and beginner-friendly design
- Hybrid tips for surgical precision
- Durable stainless steel construction
- Balanced cutting diameter (1–1 1/8 inches)
Cons
- Blades dull quickly with repeated use
- Unclear price point affects value assessment
5. TRUGLO TITANIUM X Large Game 2 Blade 100 Grain Fixed-Blade Crossbow Broadhead Grade 5 Titanium Ferrule Stainless Steel Blades
- Brand: TRUGLO
- Manufacturer: TRUGLO
The TRUGLO TITANIUM X is a high-performance broadhead designed for large game hunting. At $41.37, it features a Grade 5 titanium ferrule for unmatched strength and durability. Its double-bevel stainless steel blades create a cutting diameter of 1 3/16 inches, ensuring devastating wound channels for maximum lethality. Spin-tested and sharpness-tested, the Titanium X delivers reliable accuracy and penetration, making it ideal for elk hunters seeking a premium fixed-blade option.
In testing, the TRUGLO TITANIUM X excelled in both durability and cutting efficiency. The titanium ferrule resisted bending and damage, even after repeated impacts, while the stainless steel blades maintained their sharpness over multiple uses. However, its higher price point and limited availability may deter budget-conscious hunters. Additionally, the fixed-blade design requires careful tuning for optimal flight performance. Overall, this broadhead is a top-tier choice for hunters focused on reliability and precision in challenging hunting conditions.
Pros
- Grade 5 titanium ferrule for durability
- Double-bevel stainless steel blades
- Spin-tested for flight accuracy
- Ideal for large game hunting
Cons
- Higher price point ($41.37)
- Requires careful tuning for optimal performance
Frequently Asked Questions
We’ve compiled answers to the most common questions about broadheads for elk huntings to help you make an informed decision.
Conclusion
Choosing the right broadhead for elk hunting depends on your priorities—whether it’s cutting power, durability, or affordability.
Slick Trick XbowTrick is the top choice for seasoned hunters, while Archery World’s Bowhunting broadhead is ideal for those on a budget.
Evaluate your needs carefully to make the best decision..